Shaun wrote:
After you drive all these wagons I would be very curious about your impressions.
I suppose this should answer that question:
It's an '05 6MT, Ti Grey/Nordkap, a little more mileage than ideal, but the car is very nice. Interior is remarkably well kept for the mileage, no rust, no accidents, clean underneath, dry and quiet angle gear, good 4-C function (at least one of the front struts has been replaced, the rear shocks are likely original and I plan to replace them before too long). It probably wasn't the best driving R that I drove (I looked at an '04 with all 4 new shocks/struts), but the combination of the year, colors, overall condition and price were too much to pass up. The dealer I bought it from had it incorrectly listed on all the used car listing sites as an automatic, so I think I paid less than I might have had they listed it properly. It has all the stuff I wanted and more - cold weather package, the better audio system, roof rails and bars, 3rd row seat, ipod integration, satellite radio, brand new Toyo Proxes 4 tires... all for a price that was the second lowest I have seen for a manual V70R.
I also drove an E91 328xi - it was very nice, and felt more "at home" to me than the V70, but it didn't feel special enough for me to really want one. It was underpowered compared to my E36, the shifter was better than a stock E36 but nowhere near as good as my car, and it just did nothing to convince me it was worth over twice as much as the R I bought. Or even as much, really.
I took out an '07 manual X3 3.0 for comparison and it didn't feel THAT much different, mostly just taller. The X is not well suited for a manual though, the pitch and dive in aggressive shifting was disconcerting. SUVs just ain't me, and the only way you'd get me into one is if it were towing a racecar. I still summer DD the S2000, so that isn't a consideration for me.
Man, is this R a nice highway car though. Very deceptively fast, acceleration feels a lot more effortless than my other cars. Those seats! Great factory stereo. Seemingly every interior surface is covered in actual leather. I even got 27MPG+ on the way home, probably would have seen 29-30 if I hadn't accidentally left it in 5th on the highway for 50 miles or so . I haven't really driven it that hard yet, probably won't until I go over it (fluids, check all the rubber bits, etc). I think I'm really going to like it though.