Virus - I think I've seen this and I think I remember enjoying it.
Cemetery Man and One Hour Photo - Haven't seen these, though I've heard of OHP. Maybe more thriller than horror? Not a bad thing.
Basket Case - a classic. Haven't seen it since about 1985, but it's a treat of stop motion animation. Worth watching just for the doctors' names. If you like BC also check out The Manitou - starring a few people who should have known better.
Maximum Overdrive and Christine - seen em. Not bad, but Stephen King never seems to translate well into film. And yes, I feel that way about The Shining, too. I hate that movie. Mostly a fan of his books, though.
Human Centipede - never seen it but, while we don't mind some gore, we're more about tension and atmosphere rather than gross-out porn.
The Skeleton Key - IMDB profile looks promising. I like Peter Saarsgard and John Hurt. Sounds like we should try this one.
Babadook - Very good, agreed.
Rob Zombie's stuff - I've seen Devil's Rejects and Halloween and at least one other. DR was pretty good; Halloween was perfectly competent but unnecessary. I'm not a huge fan of remakes in general.
Mandy - not familiar with this one, but any time I see Nicolas Cage's name I think of Abed's oral report on Nicolas Cage from Community.
The Conjuring, and any sequels, tie ins - yeah, these are all pretty solid, as well as the Insidious series which also stars Patrick Wilson. That tends to make them all blend together for me, but they're all decently scary.
The Grudge - yeah, both the original and the American remake are good. Atmosphere counts. Grudge wins out over The Ring and the other Americanized Japanese horror flicks on that count.
The Hills Have Eyes - both versions also good. The problem is, since the remake, you never see the original any more.
28 Days Later - solid, as is the sequel.
Dead Alive - I know of this because it was close to being Peter Jackson's debut. Don't think I've seen it, though.
The Babysitter - Don't know this one; I'll check it out.
The Final Girls - I think I've seen this, and I think I enjoyed it. I hope I'm not thinking of Final Girl.
I Saw The Devil, Inside, Raw, Baskin, and Martyrs - Martyrs is the only one of these I have heard of, and it is highly recommended. Looks like there is a French original and an American remake of Inside. Raw looks pretty promising too. I like Byung-hun Lee so maybe we'll check out ISTD too. Thanks.
Trollhunter - I enjoyed that and I really wanted the Landie in it. It put DW to sleep.
The Exorcist / The Exorcist II - the original was great, the sequel was meh. I think there is a much later prequel, too.
Blair Witch Project - Very good, good enough to be forgiven for bringing the whole shaky-cam thing to popularity. I especially like the way the movie was made, with almost no script and real reactions. I'm familiar with that geographic area, too, which helped.
Amityville Horror - who doesn't like a good Catholic possession movie? Both versions are solid.
Pumpkinhead - a SyFy channel Halloween week classic. Disposable but fun.
The Cube series - I've seen 1 and 2. Decent, but not enough back story; a little too abstract. Maybe that's the point. Good use of very limited budgets, though.
Motel Hell - hell yeah.
The Girl With All The Gifts - yeah, that was good.
The Strangers - yeah, pretty good too. There's a similar one that came out about the same time except it's a family, not just a vacationing couple. It's also pretty good but the title escapes me.
Thanks to everybody for the suggestions. I will try to post some of my favorites but that may take a while and I'm supposed to be working. Thanks again!