2 3 4
failboat
failboat SuperDork
10/30/13 1:36 p.m.

Well the dodge is cheaper, can carry more stuff, has the 1 ton suspension, likely easier to work on than the previa, and in my experience american full size vans are pretty dang reliable.

I had an american van for several years but when i wanted to buy something with 4wd i decided to opt for an obscure 15 year old japanese minivan instead of something that you still see a lot of on the road, something basic. Not that I dislike my old MPV but its got its share of annoying, small, common, well documented problems, has unique parts that are more difficult to track down sometimes, and in general I still wish I got an astro or another fullsize.

CyberEric
CyberEric New Reader
10/30/13 1:59 p.m.
failboat wrote: Well the dodge is cheaper, can carry more stuff, has the 1 ton suspension, likely easier to work on than the previa, and in my experience american full size vans are pretty dang reliable. I had an american van for several years but when i wanted to buy something with 4wd i decided to opt for an obscure 15 year old japanese minivan instead of something that you still see a lot of on the road, something basic. Not that I dislike my old MPV but its got its share of annoying, small, common, well documented problems, has unique parts that are more difficult to track down sometimes, and in general I still wish I got an astro or another fullsize.

Thanks for the input. I'm wary of buying a 200k mile Dodge I guess is the main thing. I have a good history with Japanese cars just being like appliances for me, I just drive them and they don't need much, that's why I'm so interested in the Previa. My experience with American cars (well it has just been a '98 Explorer) has been no-starts due to sensors, solenoids, transmission issues, valve train issues, etc. So basically my history with Japanese cars is "drive it and forget it." Which is great for a work-type van.

If I buy an American van it's because I'm taking everyones word for it, which may not be a bad thing, I like the workman like feel of the domestic stuff.

Vigo
Vigo UberDork
10/30/13 11:55 p.m.

I am here to tell you that a 1998 Explorer is not a fair representation of American Car reliability in general. I would say those are noticeably worse than average.

The biggest thing to worry about with domestic full size vans is transmission issues.

That Previa looks pretty nice...

CyberEric
CyberEric New Reader
10/31/13 1:24 a.m.

Thanks Vigo, I keep hearing that, I'll keep soldiering into unfamiliar territory and watch out for transmission issues, with GRM guidance. :)

2 3 4

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
Jm0kdf9rDakyW9BEqReMdStR8e3ksxYfpB4gSGNwCBSkci1vM9UUo60vT0luDTNC