TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor
5/24/13 8:04 p.m.

TLDR S13 vs FC: handling, weight? FC +: age (25+ years old, no problems to get it on the road) S13 +: part availability, BMW swap seems easy

LS1 vs 1UZ vs M60: costs, power? LS1: cheapest huge power potential, proven swap, rear sump, by far the highest startup cost 1UZ: cheeeap, available with front/rear sump, but no stock manual transmission and expensive to boost (as most FI stuff will have to be custom made, and doesn't seem to be available for cheap in Europe) M60: cheap, available with stock manual, proven swap for s13. Findable with superchargerkit, so good power (400 hp@engine, probably potential for more) for not too much money, probably (?) front sump, not too much info on powerlevels over 400 hp, at least not with a supercharger

The BMW engine seems to be the most interesting, cost/performance wise. The FC chassis has the right age, now, so I won't have to wait to start. The oldest S13's should be OK in about half a year(production date for euro models: december 1988, according to wiki), BUT I can't say I've seen any that were that old. Most seem to be at least 1-2 year before they are old enough.

Will the BMW engine fit easy in the FC?

Full, LONG

Hi all,

I am planning to get a V8 swapped car built, as soon as my FM turbo Miata has parted out. I want big, reliable power, in a cheapish chassis and with a stock block. Reasoning behind this, is that it won't cost too much if the engine blows/car crashes.

As for the car, I prefer the styling of Jap cars. The car should be older than 25 years (or close to it), as I wouldn't be able to get it on the road otherwise, as the tuning regulations in Belgium are quite annoying. Also, I want a light chassis, I like the Lotus philosophy! The car will be stripped, and used as a weekend warrior/trackday tool/driftdays, so handling is important.

The RX-7 FC and the Nissan S13 (Silvia, 200sx, 240sx in America) seem to fit the bill, the FC has the advantage on age, the S13 has the advantage on parts availability.

As for the engine: I am considering importing a swapped car with an LS, or possibly building one here, as tax+import duty might screw me over, making an import not interesting.

The other engines I thought about, are the BMW M60 engine, and the Toyota/Lexus 1UZ. The m60 and 1uz options are waaaaaaaay cheaper and have better availability here. The bmw engine is available with a manual box, the 1uz needs some fiddling around. Another big plus, is that I might find a BMW with a supercharged m60 here. The chances that I'd find a supercharged 1UZ are second to none, making it way more expensive to get some power from. For the LS series, I'm figuring that a stock LS with a cam might be sufficient for quite while. Adding FI to them also seems to be alot cheaper.

I am looking for cars (donors) in the UK, as there is a better availability, and prices are a lot lower than they are on the mainland.

To give you an idea: M60 beemers can be found for 1000-1500 pound. There is currently one with a manual box (and lpg lol) available for 1700 pounds. A while back, there was a CF supercharged one available for 3000 pounds, also with a manual box. This made ~400 hp (engine).

1UZ cars are also available for ~1000 pounds, possibly even lower. I am not sure about the gearboxes though, and adding FI seems to be expensive if you have no fabrication skills yourself. I haven't come across a UZ-equipped car that was already supercharged/turbocharged, so I don't think they are the best option. Advantage is that they are available with front or rear sump, so fitting should be easy in both cars.

The cheapest ls (alu block) car I could find in the UK, was 6000 pounds. New engines were 4000 or 5000 pounds, gearbox was 1000-2000 pound (new afaik). On ebay is a rebuilt L33 for 1650 pounds, and an LS1 from a monaro vxr for 3350 pounds, both without gearbox. I couldn't find a second hand t56 on ebay uk, but there's a new one on there for 2850 gbp. The LS seems to be a rather easy swap into an RX7, and they are rear sumped.

Importing a 8000 USD LS1 FC to here, and getting it on the road, would end up around 10000 GBP.

I've heard about an LS swap for a silvia, from a reputed tuner/shop, that would be 8000 pounds all in(inclu engine/transmission).

The BMW swap is quite common on silvia's here, so I was told they probably have a front sump.

I had a rough estimate for 1000-1500 pounds to get the engine from the beemer in a silvia, up and running, all in. I am not sure how good the quality of the work would be, but there are some users that had there conversion done by that shop, and they seem happy.

For now, I am favoring the BMW engine, as they are quite a bit cheaper, and have decent power with the supercharger (there's a Fin on the BMW forums with over 600 hp on a stock bottom end, with an intercooled supercharger).

The LS1 is probably the cheapest if you want to go really big, but the startcost is quite expensive.

I prefer the RX7, as it is old enough right now, so I could get a toy relatively quick. The oldest euro S13's were produced in december 1988, so that's about half a year away. I didn't come across one that was that old, however, so it might be more than a year, or closer to 2 years away.

How easy would the (probably front sumped) BMW lump fit in the rx7?

Knurled
Knurled UltraDork
5/24/13 8:09 p.m.

Flathead Ford.

TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor New Reader
5/24/13 8:40 p.m.

All american V8's are equally rare here, I'm afraid...

Jaxmadine
Jaxmadine Reader
5/26/13 7:00 p.m.

5 speed fromt a toyota pickup should bolt to a 1uz. there are lots of blower kits for them as well, so no fab neccesary. (except sourcing a blower) question is, what is lighter? the fc or the s13? how easy is it to find an s110? those are even lighter:-P or even an ae86 toyota?

old_
old_ New Reader
5/26/13 9:42 p.m.
Jaxmadine wrote: 5 speed fromt a toyota pickup should bolt to a 1uz.

not without an expensive adapter

Copper280z
Copper280z New Reader
5/26/13 10:48 p.m.

TL;DR

I have a 5.3 from a chevy truck, with the LS1 camaro trimmings, and a t56 in my FC. It's a blast. I'm getting jaded to it now, but it runs 13.0 in the 1/4 mile on crap street tires, and gets 20mpg on average, much better on the highway. The aluminum truck 5.3's are ~80lbs lighter and make a bit more power.

singleslammer
singleslammer Dork
5/26/13 11:34 p.m.
old_ wrote:
Jaxmadine wrote: 5 speed fromt a toyota pickup should bolt to a 1uz.
not without an expensive adapter

Yeah, where is jax getting his info??

singleslammer
singleslammer Dork
5/26/13 11:35 p.m.
Copper280z wrote: TL;DR I have a 5.3 from a chevy truck, with the LS1 camaro trimmings, and a t56 in my FC. It's a blast. I'm getting jaded to it now, but it runs 13.0 in the 1/4 mile on crap street tires, and gets 20mpg on average, much better on the highway. The aluminum truck 5.3's are ~80lbs lighter and make a bit more power.

I would say that this is the easiest route. Order everything from American companies and bit should be straight forward enough.

Jaxmadine
Jaxmadine Reader
5/27/13 7:50 a.m.

Those adapter plates really arnt a whole lot of money. Hell, found one that will bolt the 1uz to the stock 5 speed out of the s13. Then there's no need for a trans swap.

GameboyRMH
GameboyRMH UltimaDork
5/27/13 10:47 a.m.

I think you've got it figured out: BMW M60.

singleslammer
singleslammer Dork
5/27/13 11:15 a.m.

If the lsx wasn't so easy to find here, the bmw might make more appearances

noddaz
noddaz HalfDork
5/27/13 11:16 a.m.

How about a Rover V8...?

BoxheadTim
BoxheadTim PowerDork
5/27/13 11:36 a.m.

Rover V8 should be easy to find in the UK but they're generally expensive to build up to fairly high power. If the BMW V8 fits and the OP can find one without liner damage from high-sulfur petrol, that's probably the best choice.

singleslammer
singleslammer Dork
5/27/13 11:51 a.m.

Yeah, the starting power on the Bimmer trumps the Rover out right.

TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor New Reader
5/27/13 12:26 p.m.
Jaxmadine wrote: 5 speed fromt a toyota pickup should bolt to a 1uz. there are lots of blower kits for them as well, so no fab neccesary. (except sourcing a blower) question is, what is lighter? the fc or the s13? how easy is it to find an s110? those are even lighter:-P or even an ae86 toyota?

The proper transmission to use(one that can handle decent amounts of power) would be an r154, with an adapter. Afaik it's from a toyota supra. This transmission is rather expensive, and so is the adapter plate. I read on driftworks that it would cost around £ 2k to get a conversion done from auto to manual with that transmission, that's more than the beemer costs! I will have to check for bolt on boost solutions, but I haven't come across something like that in the for sale sections, so I'm afraid it will get expensive all in, and I might have better started with an LS.

S13 seems to be a slightly lighter, stock weight at least. Not sure how it would compare if they were both equally stripped and had the same engine setup. The aluminium SR20 is rather light.

I seriously doubt I'd find an S110. RHD FC's are pretty cheap, LHD not so. Same for S13's, but an FC seems cheaper, because no one wants the rotary engine.

The AE86 is rare and expensive for what it is, far from an interesting option imo.

@Rover engine: doesn't seem to be a very interesting engine imo. No easy power, I'd like to have some room for improvements, would the "need" arise.

@BMW engine: well, it does seem to be the ideal engine here, if you don't want to go all out. But the more I think about it, the more I'd prefer the RX7 (as it's already old enough, and I can't find any 1988 S13. Even the 1989 models are pretty hard to find), and that's just wrong combo apparently :( The costs of getting it in might outweigh the cheapness compared to an ls1? The sulfur-thing shouldn't be a problem, afaik it never even was in Europe, although I'm not 100% sure of that.

@truck engine: I've seen that many people chose this option, but how about the weight and tuneability? Some examples I found (ebaying for "ls engine"): http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/CHEVY-L33-V8-ALL-ALUMINIUM-V8-ENGINE-LSX-LS1-LS6-5-3-LITRE-/290908815086?pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item43bb843eee

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Chevy-LS1-LS2-LS3-LS6-LQ4-LQ9-5-3-V8-ENGINE-DRIFT-4x4-Cobra-TVR-Rover-Hotrod-/151010432090?pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item2328ec545a

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Chevy-LS1-LS2-LS3-LS6-LQ4-LQ9-6-0-V8-ENGINE-DRIFT-4x4-Cobra-TVR-Hotrod-/151006778766?pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item2328b4958e

Does anyone know how much room there is for the oil pan on an rx7 fc? This is a side view of the bmw engine with gearbox: http://i51.photobucket.com/albums/f359/nick171/DSCF0267.jpg

Thanks for help all, by the way :) It's appreciated!

Copper280z
Copper280z New Reader
5/27/13 1:31 p.m.

The LM7 truck engine is more or less the same as an LS1 that's 80lbs heavier and lacks 400cc's, the heads are close enough to be called the same performance wise. The L33 aluminum 5.3 had better heads than an LS1 and weighs the same, it's just 400cc smaller. The ECU's are fairly interchangeable as long as the ECU matches the crank reluctor ring, all can be tuned with HP tuners. The 6.0 truck motors tend to make the same or more power than the LS1's with similar mods.

My choice, if I were to do it again and NOT find a killer deal, would be an L33. If I were you, I'd seriously consider having an engine shipped from the US if you can. Your dollar goes farther here, and the engines are MUCH cheaper. For example, I think even if shipping costs 1k usd, you would be ahead buying an L33 here.

In an FC, you NEED an LS1 camaro oil pan if you want adequate clearance.

norotors.com has tons and tons of information on GM and ford swaps, not very much if any on the toyota and bmw swaps.

TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor New Reader
5/27/13 1:43 p.m.

Yes, but it's shipping AND import (10% on item price) + tax (21% on item price+shipping costs). That ruins most options, especially for heavy items. Gearbox (T56) is also pretty serious money.

Googling for information, I came across this topic: http://www.rx7club.com/other-engine-conversions-non-v-8-118/sr20-swap-into-fc-rx-7-haters-gonna-hate-930315/ Would a custom sump like that be an option for the M60 engine? That doesn't look so complicated? Although I vaguely recall having to switch around the oil pump for something like this on the M60, from E36 V8 projects.

Why the L33 over the 6.0?

singleslammer
singleslammer Dork
5/27/13 2:20 p.m.

The l33 is the cheapest aluminum block motor. The 6.0 is iron.

GameboyRMH
GameboyRMH UltimaDork
5/27/13 2:27 p.m.
TerrorFactor wrote: Yes, but it's shipping AND import (10% on item price) + tax (21% on item price+shipping costs). That ruins most options, especially for heavy items.

Lucky you! For me it's shipping + duty (100% on item price) + broker fees! x_x

singleslammer
singleslammer Dork
5/27/13 2:38 p.m.

In reply to GameboyRMH:

You need to tell them you bought bulk cereal that only cost 30 usd.

GameboyRMH
GameboyRMH UltimaDork
5/27/13 2:48 p.m.

Haha some people try stuff like that, if you get caught you have your ass fined off though. And even stuff that's honestly cheap can be "re-valued" like an old PDA I bought for $80US that they decided had a local value of $200US.

TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor New Reader
5/27/13 2:48 p.m.
singleslammer wrote: The l33 is the cheapest aluminum block motor. The 6.0 is iron.

Owh, easy choice, thanks for clarifying. Will look into those engines a bit, might be interesting :)

EDIT: still seems quite expensive, as a lot of parts need switching over for the truck engines, and I'd still need a gearbox.

It seems that an Alpina sump+oil pump might solve the problem with the steering rack, but it costs quite a bit (650+150 pounds according to a UK bmw forum). But it would still work out quite a bit cheaper than the LS+gearbox. And I am not 100% sure it would work out, as noone seems to have done the swap yet :x

TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor New Reader
5/28/13 4:58 p.m.

Sorry for bumping this, but another question: How much would it cost to get a custum sump welded up? The sump itself is just basically a tray, so that doesn't seem to be too hard? The mounting plate could be reused like in the link I posted with the SR20 swap. That way, I'd just need to get my hands on an Alpina pump, which doesn't seem to expensive(£150), if those numbers are correct?

I've also been trying to get some rough estimates for the LS swap. I could probably keep the engine/gearbox if I'd change to an FD in a couple of years (car has to be 25+ y/o to be an option for an engine swap). That would be a car to keep forever, so that may cost a bit more :D

Copper280z
Copper280z New Reader
5/28/13 5:47 p.m.

You can use a GM T5 on an LS1 with some parts swapping, that could save, or at least delay, the cost of a t56.

TerrorFactor
TerrorFactor New Reader
5/29/13 4:29 p.m.

Getting an LS car built myself doesn't seem to be viable. The work and fabbing alone seem to cost more than an s13+bmw conversion. Granted, it might be cheaper with another shop, but the LS-swap shop did probably 90% of the RX-7's in the UK. The S13 guys did quite a bit of bmw swaps in s13's too, so it's proven stuff for both of them.

Importing might still be an option. Shipping would be ~1250-1450 gbp, depending from which coast the car comes from. Taxes+import are 30% on (car+shippingcosts).

Still way more expensive than the S13+bmw option, but it's an LS and an RX7, and I wouldn't have to wait a year or so.

I am still looking into the FC. This guy modified the sump to get the m60 in an E36: http://forums.bimmerforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=615864&page=32&p=14801922#post14801922

http://forums.bimmerforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=615864&page=33&p=14821089#post14821089

Comments on this?

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
PLgMUSgd64t0S17MDMm1E6A1MsUh7A2dW3PPXDNMgzQy1ehDqemzqXXaWv9qkEZE