Otto Maddox wrote:
In reply to Jerry From LA:
At some point, don't you have to say E36 M3 happens and not sue for the depreciation on your car for the extra 80 miles the doctor visits put on it? The shoe might be on the other foot at some point. I wouldn't want somebody nickel and diming me for their iPhone usage while they were in the doctor's waiting room because I smacked into their Camry in the carpool line.
Of course you wouldn't want that, Otto. Nobody does. However, if someone causes a loss because of stupidity, they're liable.
"E36 M3 happens" when you're climbing a mountain and get hit by rockfall from above. Or lying on a beach when a tsunami hits. Or bitten by a rattlesnake. Or attacked by a mountain lion. People have sued in these circumstances but I would not because there's no way anyone can control what nature does.
However, when someone willfully disregards either the law (in many states) or a million warnings (everywhere else) and causes a loss, you bet I will take every opportunity to restore myself to pre-accident conditions, including every nickel and dime. That is not "E36 M3 happening."
I've been hit three times by cars while running. Once I was hit hard enough to throw me into an intersection. I wasn't hurt so I got up and kept going. I could make a federal case out of any of the three incidents because the drivers were inattentive. I suffered no loss.
I've been bitten six times by dogs while running. Twice, the animals were supposedly in the control of their owners. They paid for my doctor visits, tetanus shots, deep puncture wound care, mileage, etc.
These folks and/or their insurance companies (I don't know where the money came from) were relieved because all I wanted was to be restored. They were glad because what I was asking was reasonable in light of the situation. No mental anguish. No exaggerated pain and suffering. They cut a check for a fraction of what could've happened in a protracted legal case.
As far as "the shoe being on the other foot," I live life to prevent that ever happening. I endeavor to pay attention at all times, especially behind the wheel of a car. Knock on wood, everything's gone fine so far.
My duty as a citizen of this country is to make sure any action I take does not harm anyone else. If everybody did that, this thread wouldn't be here.
PS: The incidents listed above while running occurred over the last 40 years so I'm really not a magnet for that stuff.