In reply to z31maniac :
I'm equally happy in city or country honestly. My vague rule is that I want to be within 2 hours of an IKEA.... not so much for the IKEA itself, but the locations of those stores pretty squarely aligns with a certain demographic and a certain timbre of culture that I like.
I never really worried about the money part. I know there is this whole cost of living comparison, standard of living thing, but I never gave it much thought. In college my rent was less than $500 per semester ($1400 split between three of us) for a big house. Shortly after that I lived in Los Angeles where my rent was $1550 a month and suddenly gas was $5/gallon and milk was $4/gallon. Didn't care. I made it work. I bartended on weekends and worked at a custom/hot rod shop during the week. I went from there to Southern IN working for a theater that paid for housing and stuff was cheap. I'm a go-with-the-flow kinda guy, so when I decide I want something I find a way to do the work to make it happen.
I wouldn't say I love Harrisburg, but it's the hand I was dealt and I've bloomed where I've been planted. I came back here to lick wounds after my divorce while I shopped for a new town and ended up getting an awesome job and (for a while at least) an awesome lady. I will also say that the $350 mortgage, the $46/mo heating bill, and the $80 local taxes I paid this year are pretty sweet. School taxes are high, but I'm fine with it keeping the kids educated which tends to reduce the riff-raff quotient. I live two blocks from a huge school and I leave my keys in the van and motorcycle in the driveway and never lock my garage.
Is there anywhere you have visited and thought "dude, I could totally live here?" Figure out what it is about that town and see what you come up with.
Way off the topic, but I'll suggest it anyway: My (now ex) wife and I lived in a camper for many years. 9 months in one spot, 7 years in another, 2 weeks other places. We traveled to all the places where we wanted to go and stayed until we felt we had experienced what we wanted to experience. The general mission was to live there A) long enough to feel like a local (like New Orleans, Los Angeles, and Austin), or B) long enough to determine that we didn't want to or care about feeling like a local (like Miami and Evansville). I'm not suggesting in any way that you adopt the hardcore nomad life like we did, but it does present a unique opportunity. Right now housing is abnormally inflated due to covid. If you were to move into an RV, it would allow you to do two big things: 1- capitalize on selling during the spike in housing prices without having to use it all right now buying another inflated house, and 2- lets you travel during the summer to experience a bunch of towns to see where you might want to live. Then, ditch the RV in your new town and buy a house after prices come down. For some, the thought of leaving a job without something to jump right into doesn't fit their lifestyle and I totally dig that. When I started on the road I had no job, but I had a CDL with school/passenger so I knew I could stop anywhere and find work. At the beginning I did have to pawn a watch to get gas money, but the rest was totally gravy. Working for 5 days could easily pay for a month of living. Easy to save while we got the taste of a town.
Just a thought. I figured it might not resonate with you, but it also might make you salivate. Never know, so I thought I'd suggest it.